Accessibility links

Observers See Cambodia’s Democracy in Retreat

  • Dy Khamboly
  • VOA Khmer

Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Sen (R) talks to Sam Rainsy, president of the Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP), during a plenary session at the National Assembly in Phnom Penh November 28, 2014. REUTERS/Samrang Pring

Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Sen (R) talks to Sam Rainsy, president of the Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP), during a plenary session at the National Assembly in Phnom Penh November 28, 2014. REUTERS/Samrang Pring

Government officials say limitations on freedom are necessary to avoid what they cast as the potential for catastrophic “color revolution” in Cambodia.

Political intimidation, the suppression of political expression and restrictions on freedom of assembly have Cambodia’s young democracy under threat, observers in the country say.

Government officials say limitations on freedom are necessary to avoid what they cast as the potential for catastrophic “color revolution” in Cambodia of the sort that erupted in Syria five years ago. That uprising, which began amid hopes of a democratic spring across the Arab world, has plunged the country into chaos.

Prime Minister Hun Sen argues he is defending Cambodia’s “hard-earned peace and political stability,” said Preap Kol, executive director of Transparency International Cambodia.

The government insists its actions have been legally based, but the differing treatment of pro- and anti-government demonstrators by authorities, and a series of prosecutions that appear politically motivated, suggest a double standard.

Preap Kol, Executive Director of Transparency International Cambodia, discusses corruption among Cambodian youth on VOA Khmer’s Hello VOA radio call-in show in Phnom Penh, Thursday, November 12, 2015. (Lim Sothy/VOA Khmer)

Preap Kol, Executive Director of Transparency International Cambodia, discusses corruption among Cambodian youth on VOA Khmer’s Hello VOA radio call-in show in Phnom Penh, Thursday, November 12, 2015. (Lim Sothy/VOA Khmer)

“There is a lack of fairness and social justice that is an important standard of rule of law,” said Preap Kol, who compared recent developments for Cambodian democracy to the choreography of a traditional Khmer dance. “Dancers take three steps forward and three steps backward,” he said. “It goes forward slowly. In some circumstances, it retreats back swiftly.”

The recent round of measures apparently designed to silence Hun Sen’s troublesome opponents began in August last year, when opposition senator Hong Sok Hour was arrested for falsifying public documents related to the 1979 Cambodia-Vietnam border treaty, despite having supposed immunity from prosecution as a parliamentarian.

The crackdown turned violent in October when two Cambodia National Rescue Party (CNRP) lawmakers, Nhay Chamroeun and Kong Saphea, were badly beaten outside the National Assembly by youths, apparently aligned with the ruling party, who were granted relatively broad freedom to demonstrate. The protesters were demanding that the opposition party’s deputy leader, Kem Sokha, be stripped of the parliament’s vice presidency. The official investigation into the attack has become mired in the courts.

Nhay Chamroeun, a CNRP lawmaker from Kampong Cham province, shows his surgery scar to VOA Khmer reporters on Thursday, November 26, 2015. He and lawmaker Kong Sophear were brutally attacked last month in front of Cambodia's National Assembly in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. (Neou Vannarin/VOA Khmer)

Nhay Chamroeun, a CNRP lawmaker from Kampong Cham province, shows his surgery scar to VOA Khmer reporters on Thursday, November 26, 2015. He and lawmaker Kong Sophear were brutally attacked last month in front of Cambodia's National Assembly in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. (Neou Vannarin/VOA Khmer)

Intimidation peaked in January, when charges were leveled against CNRP President Sam Rainsy, including a charge relating to sharing one of Hong Sok Hour’s allegedly faked documents on Facebook. A defamation suit against Sam Rainsy, filed some years ago by former Foreign Minister Hor Nam Hong, was swiftly reactivated, and a new defamation case was filed against the CNRP leader by National Assembly President Heng Samrin.

Sam Rainsy went back into exile for the fourth time. Thus, the “culture of dialogue” touted when the rival parties resolved a stalemate over the 2013 election was in tatters even before the latest round of judicial attacks.

CNRP lawmaker Um Sam An was arrested in April, also over comments about the Cambodian-Vietnamese border. Again, parliamentary immunity was disposed of with the argument that he was caught in the act of breaking the law. He has been denied bail and remains in jail.

Jailed Opposition Party Lawmaker Um Sam An, who was charged with incitement in April over comments he made about the border with Vietnam, at Appeal Court on Tuesday 17th , May 2016. ( Leng Len/VOA Khmer)

Jailed Opposition Party Lawmaker Um Sam An, who was charged with incitement in April over comments he made about the border with Vietnam, at Appeal Court on Tuesday 17th , May 2016. ( Leng Len/VOA Khmer)

An alleged sex scandal has also been whipped up, again involving youth activists aligned with the ruling Cambodian People’s Party. The youths have demanded that Kem Sokha face legal consequences for an alleged affair that was purportedly exposed in recordings published online.

Political analysts, civil society organizations and even a United Nations employee have been caught up in the scandal. Some are accused of coercing the alleged mistress to deny publicly the claims. Kem Sokha, in response, has stuck to his proclaimed philosophy of “no answer, no response, no argument,” and determined to surrender himself to the courts rather than choose self-exile.

The United Nations human rights agency has called the actions “politically-motivated persecution” and pointed to “woefully flawed due process” in the cases. The defamation suits against opposition lawmakers and the arrests of workers for local human rights group Adhoc were breaches “of the universal right to freedom of expression and opinion,” the agency said.

Kem Sokha talked to CNRP activists and supporters in Por Senchey district, west of Phnom Penh, on March 6, 2016. (Aun Chhengpor/VOA Khmer)

Kem Sokha talked to CNRP activists and supporters in Por Senchey district, west of Phnom Penh, on March 6, 2016. (Aun Chhengpor/VOA Khmer)

Council of Ministers spokesman Phay Siphan asserted that the government was committed to the rule of law, and said recent moves to make officials responsive to the public through social media were in fact improving freedom of expression.

“It is the balance between the use of rights and the monitoring of [people’s] rights by authorities in a democratic society,” he said

But the government’s recent actions have made the political situation “tense,” said Chak Sopheap, executive director of the Cambodian Center for Human Rights. “It is a sign of threats to other NGOs that have been working on similar issues to foster respect for human rights in Cambodia,” she said.

Chak Sopheap noted the vast quantity of government officials’ time being dedicated to the sex scandal and the broader crackdown. The government and civil society groups seemed to be speaking different languages, interpreting the concepts of rule of law and freedom of expression entirely differently, she added.

“No one is opposing what the government says about peace and development,” she said. “In fact, civil society is joining with the government to improve democracy and rule of law.”

XS
SM
MD
LG